The Red Tent
I was asked by a church member to
watch The Red Tent. I did not take
notes while I watched it, so these thoughts are not exhaustive or
comprehensive. Instead, I hope they serve as a good overview of the movie and
will guide you as you engage with other biblical movies.
First off, I am traumatized by the
number of births and birthing shots in the movie. I physically cringed in one
part. Katie and I have adopted and I am sure, if I am ever around for a real
birth I will pass out, at least that is my prayer!
The naming of the movie was a definite
marketing scheme. I did not read the book and I suspect, the book had more
workings of the tent than the movie. With multiple wives and segregation I saw
nothing that did not agree with what I have read about such a thing during the
given time period. I must note though, that such details are not included in
the Bible so it based off of secondary sources.
My main point of disagreement with
the story is the inaccuracy to the biblical text. There were two glaring areas.
The first is in Dinah falling in love with the Shechem and the slaughter of the
town. In the biblical account (Gen 34) she did not fall in love but was “seized”
and “humiliated” by Shechem. He did fall in love with Dinah but this was after
he raped her. The movie did not show this and the glaring omission left it
hollow. The movie did not include Simeon and Levi plundering the city and
taking wives which is significant.
The second area which was significantly
off from the biblical text is the meeting between Jacob and Esau (Gen 33). Esau
came with 400 men in the biblical account not 100 like what the movie said.
Also, there was distance between the two groups Jacob made when Esau came.
Jacob’s approach to Esau was much different than the movie. While these changes
in the story are minor, they are changes nonetheless and serve no purpose.
When watching biblical movies, I am
perfectly fine with creative license if
it is not in the Bible. To change the story when a detail is clearly listed
is pointless to me. However, this is the reason, I liked the grouping together
of Dinah and Joseph in Egypt. After Genesis 34, there is no mention of Dinah so
I do not believe the truthfulness of her and Joseph meeting in Egypt. But, to
think about it and see it in a movie was a rather creative idea.
I liked the movie with the
exception of the traumatic birthing scenes. I wish they would have stuck closer
to the biblical text. If they would have done so, they could have retained the
main storyline. Even though the movie has me scarred for life, I found it
entertaining and moderately enjoyable. In fact, Katie and I paused the movie
several times to read the biblical accounts and talk about the movie as it went
along.
We also talked about the take away from the movie and biblical storyline.
The movie had a main takeaway to follow your heart and marry for love. This
however, is not the point of the passage in the Bible. The story in the Bible
is quite tragic. The story is part of the larger unfolding of God’s plan to
redeem mankind through the lineage of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.
The actions of Jacob’s sons is
horrid. However, God works through such sultry people to bring about his plans
and glory. He humbled them by sending them to Egypt and had them face Joseph. Through
these wicked brothers line comes Jesus. The plans of God cannot be stopped by
the wickedness of man because God is greater than the wickedness.
The story also shows us how much
better Jesus is by way of contrast. Simeon and Levi killed all the men in an
entire city because their sister was raped. I do not want to downplay the rape
but murdering, plundering, and then taking the remaining women as wives is not
a just recompense. Personally, I was challenged to let God enact justice
because I am prone to overdo it! However, Jesus who was sinless, hung on a
cross and pleaded for the forgiveness of the men who were killing him. So while
the movie The Red Tent was not
completely biblical, let it encourage us to love Jesus more.